Home / Who's Tricking You?

Still from the episode “Who told you there are only three left?” Watch on YouTube

Who's Tricking You? · Episode 6

Who told you there are only three left?

· 82 seconds

Only three left? Usually, nobody counted.

The 1975 biscuit-jar experiment, a 1990s toy craze built on 'retired' designs, countdown clocks that restart when you refresh, and the hotel booking sites the UK watchdog made stop.

Watch on YouTube Follow on TikTok

Share this story

What the fox said

Who told you there are only three left?

Usually, nobody counted.

1975. Scientists offer people a biscuit from a jar. One jar holds ten. The other holds just two.

Same biscuits. But the ones from the nearly empty jar are rated tastier, and more wanted.

Sellers have always known this. Scarce feels valuable.

In the 1990s, a toy maker sold little beanbag animals, then retired designs on purpose.

Collectors panicked. Some paid hundreds for a toy that cost a few pounds. Then the bubble burst.

Today, it's a ticking clock on a website. Offer ends in nine minutes. Refresh the page, and sometimes it starts again.

In 2019, Britain's competition watchdog made big hotel booking sites stop misleading pressure claims, like only one room left.

Because real scarcity is rare. Fake scarcity is cheap.

A limited edition is often just a normal product, with a deadline stuck on it.

So when a clock is rushing you, ask who wound it up. Keep your nose to the wind.

Sources

  • In a 1975 experiment, people rated biscuits from a jar holding two as more desirable than identical biscuits from a jar holding ten (Worchel, Lee & Adewole, 1975).
  • Fake or resetting countdown timers on shopping websites have been documented by the UK competition regulator, which gained new consumer-law powers in 2024 (Competition and Markets Authority, online choice architecture work; Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024).
  • In February 2019 six hotel booking sites, including Booking.com and Expedia, committed to ending misleading pressure-selling claims (Competition and Markets Authority, February 2019).

Spotted a mistake? Tell us in the YouTube comments and we'll correct it.

Tags

  • only 3 left
  • fake scarcity
  • scarcity marketing
  • countdown timer
  • pressure selling
  • cma
  • consumer psychology
  • marketing tricks
  • who's tricking you
  • the old fox